Is Utica First Insurance Company hiring right now?

Utica First Insurance Company has no open roles listed as of October 23, 2026. Roles appear here as soon as they are posted on Utica First Insurance Company's careers site.

Where is Utica First Insurance Company headquartered?

Utica First Insurance Company is headquartered in Oriskany, NY, United States and was founded in 1903.

Who leads Utica First Insurance Company?

Scott A. Shatraw, President & CEO, is at the top of Utica First Insurance Company's org chart.

How do I apply for a job at Utica First Insurance Company?

Pick a role on Utica First Insurance Company's TheJobsMap page and select Apply. Every listing links to the original posting on Utica First Insurance Company's own careers site, so you apply directly with the employer.

Utica First Insurance Company jobs and careers

Oriskany, NY, United States

As of October 23, 2026, Utica First Insurance Company has no open roles listed.

uticafirst.com LinkedIn @UticaFirstInsCo

About Utica First Insurance Company

Utica First Insurance Company was founded by local Utica, New York businessmen in 1903 as Utica Fire Insurance Company of Oneida County, NY to serve the property insurance needs of the upstate New York residents. It has developed from that small base into a company which actively writes business in the states of New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia. In the beginning, the Company wrote exclusively property insurance on an assessable basis. Now its product line has expanded to include Homeowner, Landlord Package, Restaurant and Tavern Program, Convenience Store Program, Small Artisan Package Policy and Business Owner Policies among others. Facebook.com/UticaFirstInsCo Twitter.com/UticaFirstInsCo

Insurance

Founded: 1903
Employees: 125
Headquarters: Oriskany

Leadership

The top of Utica First Insurance Company's org chart, with how many people report into each leader.

Scott A. Shatraw

President & CEO

24 reports

Richard Zick

President CEO

John Burns Mba

Senior Vice President Snd Chief Information Officer

10 reports

David Jarvis

Vice President Of Agencies

7 reports

Kyle Burch

Vice President Finance

1 report

Melissa Mann Cpcu, Are, Aic, Aim

Senior Vice President Of Strategic Services

1 report

Cora Fargo

Executive Assistant

Jobs at Utica First Insurance Company

No open positions right now. Explore more companies on TheJobsMap.

Utica First Insurance Company jobs: common questions

Is Utica First Insurance Company hiring right now?: Utica First Insurance Company has no open roles listed as of October 23, 2026. Roles appear here as soon as they are posted on Utica First Insurance Company's careers site.
Where is Utica First Insurance Company headquartered?: Utica First Insurance Company is headquartered in Oriskany, NY, United States and was founded in 1903.
Who leads Utica First Insurance Company?: Scott A. Shatraw, President & CEO, is at the top of Utica First Insurance Company's org chart.
How do I apply for a job at Utica First Insurance Company?: Pick a role on Utica First Insurance Company's TheJobsMap page and select Apply. Every listing links to the original posting on Utica First Insurance Company's own careers site, so you apply directly with the employer.